Early one spring morning in 1971, John Lennon sat at a Steinway piano in his bedroom and composed one of the most popular songs of all time. His wife, Ono, watched as he fingered the final chords and crooned the closing lyrics. She said that he imagined it all in nearly one sitting.
Imagine there’s no heaven, it’s easy if you try
No hell below us, above us, only sky
Imagine all the people, livin’ for today
For fifty years, those lyrics have been drummed into my ears thousands of times – from elevators to Olympic games – so many times that I automatically hum “ah, ah, a-a-ah.”
But Lennon was wrong. Seriously wrong. Dead wrong.
It is completely needless to “imagine” no heaven because it has already been tested. Rome scoffed at heaven, and when the plagues came, the elite (even doctors) fled. Only Christians stayed to care for the dying, at the risk of their lives. Because they were living for tomorrow.
In the 20th Century, it was precisely the governments who imagined no heaven that perpetrated its greatest atrocities: Stalin’s regime killed between 10 and 20 million, Mao’s communist China between 50 and 100 million, and the Khmer Rouge genocides decimated 25% of its population.
Living for “today” turned Strawberry Fields into Killing Fields.
Living for Today
Miroslav Volf is a Croatian theologian who lived through the Balkan wars of the 1990’s. He witnessed brutalities we can’t imagine, and some of his family members experienced barbarisms from hell. In his book on lessons learned, Volf explains why he didn’t take up arms against the monsters who executed these brutalities.
If you think that an idea of a judging God leads to violence, NOT AT ALL. Violence thrives today secretly nourished by the belief in a God who refuses to wield the sword.
If, when you are hurt, your children and loved ones are hurt or beaten or raped, when your village is plundered, or destroyed; what will keep you from being sucked into the cycle of violence? Only if you believe that there is a God Himself who knows what people deserve. God will judge, I don’t have to do it.Exclusion and Embrace, slightly edited
While the overwhelming majority of 20th Century atrocities were committed by regimes hostile to religion, some were executed by people devoted to religion, like the 9/11 attack on the Twin Towers. But both groups acted from the same motivations: They just can’t let it be.
The atheist regime and the religious terrorist are living for today, not trusting in a God who will ultimately bring real justice, tomorrow.
Singing for Today
There’s something enchanting about Lennon’s Imagine. The simple chords, whimsical melody, and sweet lyrics captivate us with imaginary earthly gifts of peace and prosperity. But once we unwrap that present, we find the same Pandora’s Box that Eve opened.
Satan’s message to Eve was: “God is holding you back. Forget Him and life will be all you can imagine.” Lennon let me down with his eerie echo of Satan’s lie: “It’s God and heaven that oppress and kill. Let’s come together and just forget Him.”
Pandora’s box didn’t end suffering and death, it released them. Lennon’s lyrics spit in God’s face, and its snake-oil sweetness poisons us with a desire to do the same. Someone once said,
“It’s not those who write the laws that have the greatest impact on society. It’s those who write the songs.”
Living for Tomorrow
Hebrews chapter 11 tells us to get back to eternity. It describes heroes who suffer horrible disappointments, torture, and death. It explains the secret that sustained them through the brutality of life here and now: to consider themselves “strangers and exiles on this earth.”
They desire a better country, a heavenly one. Therefore God is not ashamed to be called their God, for he has prepared for them a city.”Hebrews 11:16
Christianity rests on the unseen God and His returning to us a new heaven and new earth. Every other declaration – even when it’s whimsical – is the voice of the world, twisting and shouting its lie that living for a visible today is better than following an invisible God.
But in my life (and yours), the promise of a future heavenly life energizes us to live in the today:
- They say of temporal suffering, “No future bliss can make up for it,” not knowing that Heaven, once attained, will work backwards and turn even that agony into glory. (CS Lewis)
- I believe like a child that suffering will be healed and made up for … that in the world’s finale, something so precious will come to pass that it will suffice for all the crimes of humanity … that it will make it not only possible to forgive but to justify all that has happened. (Dostoevsky)
- Perhaps Sam Gamgee said it best after his ordeal to Mt. Doom: “I thought you were dead! But then I thought I was dead myself! Is everything sad going to come untrue?” Who in their right mind would ever want to “live [merely] for today”? After all, tomorrow, Here comes the Son.
Dear Lord, let it be!
© Copyright 2021, Beliefs of the Heart, Ltd. All rights reserved.
Top photo credit: Famous Imagine symbol of the John Lennon Wall in Prague, Czech Republic, from Bigstock.com, copyright by modzele2, stock photo ID 8200682
Sam Williamson grew up in Detroit, Michigan, USA. He is the son of a Presbyterian pastor and grandson of missionaries to China. He moved to Ann Arbor, Michigan in 1975. He worked in London England from 1979 to 1982, helping to establish Antioch, a member community of the Sword of the Spirit. After about twenty-five years as an executive at a software company in Ann Arbor he sensed God call him to something new. He left the software company in 2008 and now speaks at men’s retreats, churches, and campus outreaches. His is married to Carla Williamson and they have four grown children and grandchildren. He has a blog site, www.beliefsoftheheart.com, and can be reached at Sam@BeliefsoftheHeart.com.
1 thought on “Imagine There’s No Heaven – Livin’ for Today”
Thanks very much for this level-headed and very helpful response to the attitude expressed in the popular, but also poisonous song. God bless you!