Early
Growth and
Development of
the Catholic
Charismatic
Renewal
by
Fr.
Pat Egan
Introduction
The Spirit comes with long preparation and
lasting effects, but on occasion he arrives at a
dramatic moment that can be set down precisely.
His coming on Pentecost, with rushing wind,
tongues of fire, and gifts of' praise and
preaching, occurred at just 9:00 a.m.
The modern Pentecostal movement was launched at
Bethel Bible School in Topeka, Kansas, on the
evening of January I, 1901, when Annie Ozman
began to praise God in an unknown tongue. The
birth of the contemporary charismatic renewal in
the Catholic Church can be as precisely dated to
the evening of Saturday, February 17, 1967.
The Duquesne Weekend Retreat
Two theology professors at Duquesne University,
in Pittsburgh, and students in a Christian
"study and action" group gathered for a
retreat that February weekend. The professors
had experienced a release of the Holy Spirit
after reading
The Cross and the Switchblade,
a first-person story by Pentecostal minister
David Wilkerson, and through the prayers of some
Episcopalians, but they had not described this
to the students. Student speakers came with
notebooks crammed with comments on the Acts of
the Apostles - the text for the retreat - but no
idea of an experiential encounter with the Holy
Spirit.
That, however, was exactly what God had in mind.
Speakers found themselves making statements
about the power of the Spirit that went beyond
anything in their notes. One speaker was
interrupted several times by prayer and praise,
and began praying in tongues during the applause
and worship that broke out at the end of her
presentation.
The well at the retreat-house stopped working on
Saturday morning, almost forcing an early end to
the retreat. But it started again in the
afternoon after prayer. The young man who
discovered that the water was running rushed to
the chapel to thank God, where he found himself
overwhelmed-literally prostrated-by the presence
of God.
That evening students came one by one to the
chapel and unexpectedly experienced the reality
of God's love for them. To some the chapel
seemed to grow brighter, to others hotter. The
young people knelt, saying over and over, "Yes,
Lord," Of, "I love you, Jesus." Praying for one
another and worshiping on their knees, singing
and worshiping in tongues, they remained in the
chapel until 3:00 a.m.
Without any human design, the Catholic
Pentecostal movement had begun.
After the weekend, the participants found
themselves in a new dimension of spiritual
power. They continued to experience a sense of
God's presence, gifts of tongues, prophecy, and
healing, a thirst for prayer and scripture, an
effectiveness in telling others about Christ.
Some of the participants in that 1967 weekend
began lives of serious Christian service which
have continued to the present day.
From this beginning at the "Duquesne Weekend"
Pentecostal renewal has spread around the world
to millions of Catholics. [Current estimates are
some 120 million Catholics in 235 countries
around the world.]
Since the Duquesne weekend Pentecostal renewal
has brought nominal Catholics to personal faith
in Christ and serious Catholics to new depths of
fervor and service. It has stimulated personal
prayer and evangelism and has brought a new
liveliness to corporate worship, sacred music,
and Bible reading. This renewed personal faith
has led to increased ecumenical awareness among
Catholics and the growth of countless local
groups, regional centers and communities, and
the reappearance of spiritual gifts on a wide
scale in the Catholic Church.
The influence of the Cursillo
on the charismatic renewal
The movement is one of the wonders of God in our
day. How has it achieved such remarkable growth?
Among the original group of students and recent
graduates baptized in the Holy Spirit in
February 1967 were some already passionately
involved in evangelism and church renewal,
notably in the Cursillo movement, an
evangelistic movement begun in Spain after World
War II. Not only were they keen and zealous;
they had established networks with other young
Catholic leaders of similar outlook, especially
students at Notre Dame University, in South
Bend, Indiana, and recent graduates. Among these
were Kevin and Dorothy Ranaghan, Stephen Clark,
Ralph Martin, Bert and Mary Lou Ghezzi, Philip
O'Mara, George and Mary Martin, and Kerry and
Barbara Koller.
These young men and women were well-educated,
intelligent, deeply committed Christians, loyal
to their church. They formed the matrix in which
charismatic renewal spread rapidly among
Catholics and developed into a movement seeking
to be a force for renewal within the Catholic
Church rather than apart from it.
Their deep desire for integration in the wider
Catholic Church was soon reciprocated by
Catholic authorities who moved from suspicion to
watchfulness to cautious acceptance, and, in
some cases, to personal endorsement and even
vigorous approval.
Many times God acted powerfully and in startling
ways to win approval for the fledgling movement.
Just as God had once inspired both Peter and
Cornelius in order to open the church to
gentiles, so now he worked simultaneously in the
hearts of high ecclesiastics and these young lay
leaders. Vigorous leadership by Bishop Joseph
McKinney, of Grand Rapids, Michigan, and
Cardinal Leo-Joseph Suenens, of
Malines-Brussels, Belgium, and powerful friends
in Rome soon won the support of many bishops and
gave the new movement world-wide credibility.
Favorable factors for rapid
growth
The Catholic charismatic renewal turned out to
have been launched at a strategic time and
place. Just as the
pax romana
contributed to the spread of the New Testament
church, so many modern factors contributed to
the spread of Catholic charismatic renewal from
the United States in 1967: the wide diffusion of
the English language and American influence; the
Catholic Church's openness to change after the
Second Vatican Council; the evident weakness of
current Catholic pastoral methods in the face of
secular culture; a new Catholic ecumenical
spirit; a significant declericalization and
democratization in the Catholic Church; the
accessibility of the media to Christians in the
United States. This unique combination of
favorable factors enabled the Catholic
Pentecostal renewal to expand with astonishing
speed.
But even these are not explanations enough. When
he convened the Vatican Council in 1961, Pope
John XXIII asked Catholics all over the world to
pray for "a new Pentecost in our day and a
renewal of faith, with signs and wonders."
Catholic charismatic renewal is best understood
as God's wonderful answer to that prayer.
The 1970s:
brushfire growth
The late 1960s and the 1970s were a time of
rapid growth for the Catholic charismatic
movement in the United States, evidenced by the
appearance and expansion of conferences and
publications. The hub of early activities was
Indiana and Michigan. In September 1967 a
meeting of 50 people was held at Notre Dame
University, which became an annual national
conference, continuing to the present. The
annual conferences at Notre Dame drew 5,000
participants from 10 nations, including 3
bishops and 23.0 priests, in 1971; and to 11,000
participants, including 6 bishops and 400
priests, in 1972. By the following year, when
attendance reached 20,000, participants came
from all 50 states and 25 foreign nations.
The spectacle of supposedly staid Catholics
enthusiastically expressing their faith and love
of God intrigued the media, who followed these
annual conferences closely. The rallies received
extensive and generally sympathetic press
coverage; front page pictures impressed the
imagination of many Catholics.
May 1968 saw the first national leaders
conference at Ann Arbor, Michigan. These
continued for several years afterwards at New
Year's, beginning with 53 attendees in 1969 and
increasing to 500 by 1971.
A stenciled
Pastoral Newsletter for
leaders in the movement was begun in Michigan in
May 1969. In June 1970 it became an eight-page
printed publication, which climbed to a
circulation of 1,200 in the United States and
abroad. Renamed
New Covenant in July
1971, the periodical became a 64 page popular
monthly, which reached a circulation of over
70,000 subscribers in more than 100 nations in
the mid 1980s.
To facilitate the spread of the renewal plans
were made in the spring of 1969 for a national
communication center, which was set up in South
Bend and later evolved into the present
Charismatic
Renewal Services. By the beginning of the
1980s
CRS was shipping more than a ton
of books and other materials a day.
By the end of the 1970s the period of most
rapid, visible growth in the movement in the
United States seemed to be coming to an end. The
circulation of New Covenant stabilized.
The largest annual charismatic renewal
conference at South Bend took place in 1976,
drawing 30,000 participants. After this the
total number of people attending regional and
city-wide conferences across the country
continued to grow, but the sense of constant
vigorous expansion in the movement faded. The
largest Catholic charismatic renewal conference
took place during this period, in 1977, when a
regional conference in Atlantic City, New
Jersey, brought together 35,000 Catholics.
Recognition
In 1970 a "service committee" of six laymen and
two priests was formed to take responsibility
for the communication center, the national
conferences in South Bend, the leaders'
conferences in Ann Arbor, and the beginnings of
New Covenant. Soon, an Advisory
committee" of 26 members was also formed to help
guide the service committee's work. The
National
Service Committee, which was renamed
Chariscenter
USA, has not attempted to direct the
Catholic charismatic renewal but to strengthen
it by offering conferences, publications, and
counsel.
Bishop Alexander Zaleski, of Lansing, Michigan,
in whose diocese much of the early activity was
taking place, recommended to the national
assembly of Catholic bishops that the movement
be received with cautious approval and that the
bishops assist it by providing it with the
leadership of wise and experienced priests. This
essentially foreshadowed the approach taken by
the assemblies of Catholic bishops in the United
States and other countries, and by the Vatican.
An important aspect of the Chariscenter's work
has been to develop lines of communication
between the movement and the bishops and clergy.
An early meeting was held with a bishops'
working group in March 1971. Individual contacts
with local bishops followed, leading to the
appointment of priests as liaisons in most
dioceses to facilitate communications between
the bishop and the movement in each diocese.
These liaisons, in nun, have formed a national
association for communication among themselves.
The bishops as a body have also established a
standing committee to relate to the overall
charismatic renewal.
Initiation and expansion
One of the major achievements of the group of
early leaders was to discover how to introduce
Catholics in a stable and enduring way to new
life in the Holy Spirit, with its personal
relationship to Jesus, expectant faith, and
empowerment for witness. How could this new life
be sustained after the initial emotion of
Pentecostal conversion faded? The "Life in the
Spirit Seminars," which used a catechumenate
method for Christian initiation and incorporated
the newcomer into an active fellowship of
believers, provided this for thousands, perhaps
millions, of Catholics in many different parts
of the world.
In the seventies, shaped by its capable and
methodical North American leaders, the Catholic
charismatic renewal expanded outside the United
States. Through North American missionaries who
met the renewal while on home leave, or as
guests of prayer groups and renewal communities,
the movement spread quickly, first to Canada and
France, then all around the world.
Major theologians soon realized the potential of
the movement, among them Avery Dulles and Kilian
McDonnell in the United States, Heribert Muehlen
in Germany, and Louis Bouyer in France. Their
interest led others to take the movement
seriously.
In 1973, at Cardinal Suenens's urging, the first
international leaders conference was held in
Rome, where several prayer groups had already
been established by North American students in
the theology schools. As time went by, Italian,
French, and Spanish-speaking prayer groups
developed among theology students in Rome, who
spread charismatic renewal as they returned home
on graduation. The international leaders meeting
in Rome in 1973 brought together 120 men and
women from 34 nations. Thirteen leaders at this
conference were invited to meet Pope Paul VI,
and his address of welcome was printed in full
in
L 'Osservatore Romano, the Vatican's
official newspaper, with a worldwide
'circulation.
Contacts like these made possible a great Rome
conference in 1975, when 7,000 Catholics, led by
Cardinal Suenens, descended on the city. At the
conclusion of the conference Pope Paul offered
Cardinal Suenens the privilege of using the
papal altar, and so the closing liturgy was
celebrated at St. Peter's itself. There the
closing prophecies of the conference were given
and the Pope addressed the participants. The
pictures of this event showed that Catholic
charismatic renewal had indeed arrived!
Pope Paul VI had responded to the movement's
desire for official approval by giving it his
blessing. Now many influential churchmen
followed suit, among them Cardinals Miguel
Miranda in Mexico, Basil Hume in London, and
Reginald Delargey in New Zealand.
In the same year [1975] the International
Communication Office moved from Brussels to
Rome, where it is now housed in offices
belonging to the Vatican. By the end of the
1970s, then, in the United States and around the
world, ecclesiastical approval had been sought
and had been received, lines of communication
were in place, and the time had arrived for
charismatic renewal to flower in the Catholic
Church, especially in Latin America and Africa.
In 1977 more than 50,000 people from over a
dozen Christian traditions in the U.S. gathered
in Kansas City, Missouri, for the first
ecumenical charismatic conference. Ecumenism was
highlighted as a major thrust of the charismatic
renewal.
[This
article was first published in Pastoral
Renewal Magazine, September 1986]
Sources on early
history and development of
Catholic Charismatic Renewal:
- Before
Duquesne: Sources of the Renewal,
by Jim Manney: This is a
fuller description of the antecedents of
the charismatic renewal, written soon
after the movement began (1973) and
written by someone who knew the chief
events and leaders. From New Covenant
Magazine, February 1973.
- It
Was the Time and Place,
by Steve Clark:
This is a “testimony”
requested by Patti Gallagher Mansfield
for the second edition of her book As
By a New Pentecost. It is perhaps
the best place to begin, because it
gives an overview in somewhat short
form, both of the antecedents and the
continuation afterwards.
- The
Beginnings of the Life in the Spirit
Seminars, by Steve Clark:
From the fiftieth
anniversary issue of Pentecost
Today, a short description of
the beginnings of the Life in the Spirit
Seminars, one of the more important
instruments for developing the
charismatic renewal from the beginnings.
- A
Collection of Important Source
Documents for the Beginnings of the
Catholic Charismatic Renewal,
including: Early
Structure of the Catholic
Charismatic Renewal,
and Comments
on the Early History of CCR,
by Steve Clark
- A Vision for
Christian Community, by
Michael Shaughnessy, and A
Pioneer of Ecumenical Covenant
Communities, by Paul
Dinolfo, Living Bulwark, May 2009
- As
By A New Pentecost, by Patti
Gallagher Mansfield, Amor
Deus Publishing, 1992, 2016.
- Trends:
Catholic Charismatic Renewal Nears
20-Year Mark, by Fr. Pat Egan,
Pastoral Renewal, September 1986, Ann
Arbor.
[Fr. Pat
Egan is a Priest-Sociologist and Chaplain
to the Ave Maria Foundation and a
regular broadcaster on scripture on WDEO
and its affiliate, located in Ann Arbor,
Michigan, USA. He was.ordained
in London, England, and since 1980 he has
been active fin Catholic charismatic
renewal, ecumenism, and in lay movements in
the United States and abroad. He is the
founder of the Ann Arbor Catholic Men's
Movement and has served as liason for the
national Catholic Men's Movement and Promise
Keepers.